Optical interconnect technology meets standards

Feb. 1, 1998

Optical interconnect technology meets standards

New components, applications, and standards are driving parallel optical interconnect development, while advances in optoelectronics simultaneously improve dynamic range and reduce power consumption.

WAGUIH ISHAK and KIRK S. GIBONEY, Hewlett-Packard Laboratories

Several companies have recognized the potential of parallel optical interconnect technology for meeting rapidly evolving data-transmission applications such as telecommunications switching or computer networks and clusters. Many of these companies are also pursuing design efforts based on vertical-cavity surface-emitting lasers (vcsels). The Parallel-Optical Link Organization (polo), an industrial consortium led by Hewlett-Packard Laboratories (HP), Palo Alto, CA, which just completed its final year in July, was one of these efforts. During its three-year tenure, polo developed first- and second-generation prototypes, polo-1 and polo-2, of a vcsel-based parallel optical interconnect device. This article describes key technical considerations that went into prototype development.

The polo-1 and polo-2 10-channel modules are based on 980- and 850-nm vcsels, respectively. The respective aggregate data-transmission rates of the two prototypes are 6 and 10 Gbits/sec (see table). The polo-2 module is also the first multichip module (mcm) packaged with a ball-grid array (bga). In addition to device development, the full-design approach taken by the polo consortium included packaging and interconnection technologies as well as standards. HP partners in the polo consortium included

amp Inc., Harrisburg, PA, a developer of connectors and housings that contributed a latched, push-pull, multichannel, MT-ferrule-based optical connector, as well as a receptacle housing to the polo design

University of Southern California (USC),

Los Angeles, CA, which provided a link adapter chip that bridges the high-speed signaling of polo with wider cmos buses for computer applications

E. I. DuPont de Nemours, Wilmington, DE, which provided polymer waveguides

sdl Inc., San Jose, CA, which devel-

oped an edge-emitting laser-based parallel optical link module.

The polo-1 prototype performs all transmit and receive functions on a single 4 ¥ 4-cm, quad flat-pack, lead-frame mcm. The electrical interface is differential ecl or pecl. The optical interface is designed for 62.5-micron core multimode fiber and uses (DuPont) Polyguide waveguides. MT ferrules mate in a retainer-type housing.1

Components and assembly

During the development of polo-1, standards committees chose the 850-nm wavelength for local area networks. And in response, HP developed 850-nm vcsel technology for data-communications links that were used in the polo-2 prototype.2,3

The change in wavelength also necessitated a change in photodetector, because the indium gallium arsenide pin photodetectors used in polo-1 do not perform well at 850 nm. Silicon pin photodetectors are commonly used at this wavelength, but their performance is plagued by low responsivity and by response tails due to absorption in the p region.

Gallium arsenide (GaAs) metal-semiconductor-metal (msm) semiconductors offer better responsivity and speed characteristics. In addition, these devices are fabricated in a simple, two-mask process without critical alignments. An aluminum gallium arsenide surface layer provides the passivation to eliminate low frequency gain (see Fig. 1).4

In the polo-2 prototype, with an 850-nm vcsel and a 200-micron-square msm photodetector, rise- and falltimes of less than 100 psec and less than 250 psec, respectively, were achieved. Small signal bandwidth was greater than 1.5 GHz, and DC responsivity was about 0.35 A/W. Large photodetector dimensions allowed easy alignment with tolerances of 䕖 microns for the photoreceiver.

polo-2 also was designed to be the first optoelectronic integrated mcm with a bga (see Fig. 2). Higher-density connections through the bga allowed the overall package dimensions to be reduced to 23.4 sq mm. The ball pitch was industry standard at 50 mil, and the multilayer mcm incorporated multiple power and ground planes, extensive bypassing, controlled impedance lines, and thick-film termination resistors in the substrate.

The use of conventional technologies, where possible, in the design of polo-2 facilitated the use of automated production methods. Polyguide waveguides provided the optical interface, and alignment tolerances of 10 to 20 microns for transmitter waveguides and greater than 50 microns for receiver waveguides would allow fiducial alignment for production assembly. amp developed the mpx latched push-pull connector as well as polo-2 housing with mpx-connector receptacles specifically for the polo project. The overall design of the module and housing isolates the bga from mechanical forces at the connector (see photo on page 115).


Receiver sensitivity in polo-2 was measured to be about -17 dBm in fiber with a dynamic range of 23.5 dBm at 10-9 bit-error rate (ber). Optical-transmitter output power was uniform across the 10 channels, which is important in DC-coupled receivers because of the common threshold for all channels.

For a DC-coupled, unlatched (not retimed) polo-2 module at 1 Gbit/sec using a 27-1 pseudorandom-bit sequence (prbs), the observed rise- and falltimes were less than 350 psec, and duty-cycle distortion was less than 10%. Jitter on the rising edge of the waveform was caused by the pattern dependence of vcsel output. The turn-on delay of the vcsels depends on their history: the longer they are off, the longer the turn-on delay. Biasing the lasers at or just below threshold minimized this effect while maintaining a high extinction ratio. All channels ran error-free during ber measurements to less than 10-14.

Delay through the polo module was small compared to the optical delay in a fiber of a few meters. For long fiber ribbons, variations in propagation velocities can result in significant interchannel skew.5 Low-skew fiber ribbon can be made simply by assembling the ribbon with consecutive lengths from the same fiber pull, which typically resulted in less than 1-psec/m delay variation. Transmission over 300 m of low-skew ribbon fiber at 1 Gbit/sec was also demonstrated with a polo-2 module.

The AC-coupled receiver offered the advantage of greater channel-to-channel dynamic range at the expense of requiring a DC-balanced AC signal on every channel. The power uniformity was relaxed compared to a DC-coupled receiver. Channel-to-channel dynamic range in polo-2 was measured to be greater than 8 dB. For comparison, a channel fails in a DC-coupled module when its average power drops 3 dB below the threshold power.

Applications and markets

Immediate applications for parallel optical links are in high-performance parallel-data systems such as telecommunications switching and computer networks. In telecommunications central switching offices, switch clusters are sometimes connected across distance of hundreds of meters. The entire network must be robust and must be reconfigurable while operating. For the telecommunications industry, parallel optical interconnects hold out the promise of overcoming the bulk and distance limitations of copper interconnects.

Next-generation computer processors will have clock rates approaching 600 MHz, and even 1-GHz processors are on the drawing board. These clock rates will necessitate tens of gigabytes per second interconnections within computer systems. Parallel optical interconnects offer a matched, low-latency solution for high-throughput networks of workstations and distributed, multiprocessor systems. As an aid in providing such solutions, usc has developed a link adapter chip that interfaces a polo module with a workstation bus.6

Recently, HP Laboratories developed vcsel devices with extremely low threshold currents (below 200 µA) and was able to modulate these devices at 10 Gbits/sec. In a few years, packaging technology will probably be advanced enough to allow fabrication of large vcsel and detector arrays with modulation speeds in the 10-Gbit/sec/channel range. With this in mind, it is reasonable to predict interconnect modules using 32 vcsels with a total aggregate data rate of 300 Gbits/sec.

A program has been initiated at HP to commercialize polo concepts and technologies. And a product-development team is focused on meeting the needs of relevant markets. This program encompasses a family of products, such as appropriate numbers and types of channels that will target classes of applications. A road map for addressing market needs has been defined. In February 1996, HP introduced its first commercial vcsel-based transceiver product and plans to expand this offering into a variety of multichannel optical link modules.2


polo represents efforts of several individuals and organizations. Contributions of the following people are gratefully acknowledged: Kenneth H. Hahn, Joseph Straznicky, Christopher Kocot, Eric G. Wong, Tsu-Yau Chuang, Michael R. Tan, Richard P. Schneider, and David W. Dolfi at Hewlett-Packard Laboratories; Robert E. Wilson, Peter H. Mahowald, Frank Flens, Jeffrey A. Schnur, R. Daniel Rausch, and C. Steven Joiner at Communications Semiconductor Solutions Div., Hewlett-Packard Co.; Erwin H. Mueller, Alan E. Plotts, and Dale D. Murray at Optical Interconnection Systems, amp Inc.; Joseph E. Marchegiano and Bruce L. Booth at Central Research and Development Laboratories, E. I. DuPont De Nemours and Co.; Barton J. Sano, Bindu Madhaven, Barath Raghavan, and Anthony F. J. Levi at the Department of Electrical Engineering, University of Southern California. polo is supported by darpa contract number mda 972-94-3-0038 and benefits from the guidance of program manager Anis Husain. u


1. K. H. Hahn et al., ieee Proc. 46th Electron. Component. & Technol. Conf., 301 (May 28-31, 1996).

2. Hewlett-Packard 850-nm Gigabit Ethernet Fiber Optic vcsel 1X9 Transceiver, hfbr-5305 (1996).

3. K. H. Hahn et al., Electron. Lett. 29, 1482 (August 1993).

4. M. Klingenstein et al., Solid State Electronics 37(2), 333 (1994).

5. S. Siala et al., Electron. Lett. 30, 1784 (Oct. 1994).

6. B. Sano, B. Madhavan, and A. F. J. Levi, Electron. Lett. 32(24), 2262 (Nov. 21, 1996).

Waguih Ishak is director of the communications and optics research laboratory and Kirk S. Giboney is a member of the technical staff at Hewlett-Packard Laboratories, Palo Alto, CA.

This article is reprinted from the Dec. 1997 issue of Laser Focus World, another PennWell publication.
Fig. 1. Switching from a 980-nm vcsel in polo-1 to the 850-nm vcsel in polo-2 required fabrication of a GaAs metal-semiconductor-metal photodetector (top) to improve responsivity.
Fig. 2. The ball-grid array (bga) interface in polo-2 facilitated higher connection density and a reduction in device dimensions. The use of conventional technologies facilitated automated production methods.

The complete POLO-2 prototype module included an mpx connector and mt wave-guide. The design of the module and housing isolated the ball-grid array from mechanical forces at the connector.

Sponsored Recommendations

The Journey to 1.6 Terabit Ethernet

May 24, 2024
Embark on a journey into the future of connectivity as the leaders of the IEEE P802.3dj Task Force unveil the groundbreaking strides towards 1.6 Terabit Ethernet, revolutionizing...

Data Center Interconnection

June 18, 2024
Join us for an interactive discussion on the growing data center interconnection market. Learn about the role of coherent pluggable optics, new connectivity technologies, and ...

The Pluggable Transceiver Revolution

May 30, 2024
Discover the revolution of pluggable transceivers in our upcoming webinar, where we delve into the advancements propelling 400G and 800G coherent optics. Learn how these innovations...

Advancing Data Center Interconnect

July 31, 2023
Large and hyperscale data center operators are seeing utility in Data Center Interconnect (DCI) to expand their layer two or local area networks across data centers. But the methods...